What are there more of: rectangle or triangle blocks?
Based on experiments by Piaget, used by Zvonkin in his math circle.
First we lined up 8 rectangle and 7 triangle blocks. Which are there more of? It was clear that there were more rectangle blocks. Then lined up 7 of each in rows of the same length. Then, it was clear that there were the same number of each. But when I spread the triangles apart (see below) and asked "are there more triangles or rectangles" most thought there were more triangles. But then they thought about it
Then I pushed all of the triangle blocks together. Which were there more of?
Which is longer?
After working on the 'what are there more of for a while, we went into "which line is longer". And we did different permutations of this: rectangles on their long or short edge, triangles on the long or short side. Below, I thought that the rectangles on their long side and triangles on their short sides would make lines of the same length. But, this was not correct. Each triangle is just a bit shorter so when lined up the row of triangles is shorter.
Odd one out
from Zvonkin
Put together sets of cards. First three, then more. We started easy, like the one below (giraffe, lion, snake):
Later we moved onto more challenging sets with no clear answer:
These weren't as easy as counting the number of legs. For [elephant rhino lamb], the lamb was seen as the odd one because it was furry! For [chicken, eagle, flamingo] all were stuck until one child chose the eagle as the odd one out because it had long claws.
Symmetry
Last, we moved to drawing symmetry. I started with a connect four, trying to have students repeat patterns I made on one side, but it was difficult for them to understand the symmetry. So I went back to some exercises we did last year: I folded a post-it note, and drew on one side, and then students drew across the line of symmetry.
After they had the 'symmetry' down, I tried a more difficult challenge: the original drawing crossed the line of symmetry. This was confusing even though I tried a few permutations.
Admittedly, this one was pretty tough: